It Happened in Flatbush

Frank 'Butterfingers' Maguire

Kathryn Baker

Mrs. 'Mac' McAvoy

Sam Sloan

Danny Mitchell

Mrs. Maguire

Roy Collins aka Roy Anderson

Squint

Walter Rogers

Umpire Shaunnessy

Mr. Maguire

O'Doul

J.C. Scott - Catcher

Pat O'Hara - Pitcher

Stevenson - First Baseman

The Judge

Mr. Collins

Mrs. Collins

Ruth (uncredited)

Team Trainer (uncredited)